personally i'm digging the info on the silver. the 2000+ extra miles is a drop in the bucket and the frame sliders show an appreciation for care that the previous owner held. go with your gut tho, bro. or list out the pros and cons of each ride and go with the one that is clearly the winner in your book. if there is an obvious variance, but you still can't go with the top bike, then you've already subconsciously made a decision...